Breaking POET Authentication with a Single Query

In this short article, we describe a very practical and simple attack on the authentication part of POET authenticated encryption mode proposed at FSE 2014. POET is a provably secure scheme that was designed to resist various attacks where the adversary is allowed to repeat the nonce, or even when the message is output before verifying the validity of the tag when querying the decryption oracle. However, we demonstrate that using only a single encryption query and a negligible amount of computations, even without any special misuse from the attacker, it is possible to generate many valid ciphertext/tag pairs for POET. Our work shows that one should not use POET for any application where authentication property is required. Furthermore, we propose a possible patch to overcome this particular issue, yet without backing up this patch with a security proof.